The Shrimp That Barked

How Science Communication Needs to Change for a Rebuilding Era

For years, I’ve incorrectly told people that I’m partially responsible for the notorious science non-scandal, Shrimp on a Treadmill. I was the editor-in-chief of The Biological Bulletin when the Scholnick paper was published in 2006. It turns out my guilt was misplaced. That paper has no treadmill. The 2006 paper measured resting oxygen uptake and lactate in shrimp injected with Vibrio. The treadmill came later, in a SICB abstract with the famous YouTube video.

Do I feel bad about the pithy phrase (not even the title of the article) that became the battle cry for the anti-NSF coalition that eventually resulted in the challenges we have today? Yes. Do I feel sorry about publishing the science? No. It was excellent science aimed at revealing the metabolic costs of bacterial infection in a commercially relevant species.

I spent another decade at the Journal and was still editor during part of the time I was heading up biological sciences at the then-still-robust NSF. But the field and curiosity-based science paid a price for the Shrimp, and we’d be foolish to ascribe the current US science pains entirely to the malevolent genius of ideological budget-hawks. How did the shrimp paper, along with several other high-profile examples, become the emblems that they did?

To answer this question, I had to mentally time-travel back to my postdoctoral training at NIH and Woods Hole. Then, a critical step in getting a new scientific finding into top journals was making it past editorial triage. In those days, that often required a long, well-crafted cover letter to the handling editor. The barrier was partly attention: the letter had to grab enough attention to elicit at least a serious full read of the submitted manuscript. The way to that success was often a clever title, aimed less at a future science community reader than at the individual editor. The stakes were sufficiently high that perhaps we got a little too enamored with the turn of a phrase.

What I didn’t appreciate at the time was that we were training a reflex, not just writing letters. The skill was making a finding grabbable: compressing months of work into a phrase that would stop a busy reader mid-stack. And around the turn of the century, the reader we were writing for changed. NSF had already made “broader impacts” a formal review criterion, and universities were building press offices that measured success in pickups. We were told, correctly, that public support depended on public attention. So the same instinct that once aimed at a single handling editor turned outward toward reporters, department webpages, and eventually YouTube.

That is exactly how the shrimp got loose. Scholnick didn’t put “treadmill” in the title of anything. He shot a short video and posted it on his faculty page to recruit students. Someone lifted it, it went viral, and within a couple of years he and Lou Burnett were demonstrating a running shrimp on the Today show. Every step was the outreach we had been asking scientists to do. Then, in 2011, Senator Coburn’s Wastebook picked up the very image we had made so easy to remember and attached a $3 million price tag that never existed. A phrase built to be grabbed is grabbable by anyone.

That ‘getting past the gate’ call to attention leaked heavily into the culture and eventually put a lot of science at risk–particularly in disciplines that were already under the microscope for perceived left-wing leanings. Eventually, that focus on the primacy of science communication to the public transformed from the positives of television programs hosted by the likes of Alan Alda, Carl Sagan, and Bill Nye into ammunition for an ideological attack on science itself. Part of that shift came from the pressure to grab attention, and that’s on us.

It’s worthwhile noting that the large chunks of American science that don’t do this (think the national labs) haven’t had the same acute negative backlash from the folks currently in charge. And without naming programs, there are definitely activities in those quiet corners that would naturally be an ideological target. But they aren’t. They’re thriving, in fact. So there’s a lesson there. The lesson isn’t to go radio silent; it’s that they talk about their missions rather than their grants.

When we rebuild NSF and NIH, as we must, we should consider a new model for science communications, one that focuses on the global activity as a whole (beating diabetes), rather than the individual projects (GLP-1 receptor drugs). The initial discovery of exendin-4 in the spit of Gila Monsters was the first cousin of the shrimp story. But the drugs, as they stand today, are one of the most consequential pharmacological impact stories of our era. Told as lizard spit, it’s a Wastebook entry; told as part of beating diabetes, it’s a home run.

If you think about it, that’s really an old model for communicating science to stakeholders. The best science ambassadors weren’t PIs promoting their own laboratories. They were credible to the community, yet adept at painting the big picture. Vannevar Bush was such an individual. And so was Carl Sagan. More recently, my own NSF boss, France Córdova, was such a science ambassador: an astrophysicist who spoke to the value of understanding the rules of biology as cogently as she talked about gravitational waves.

Support for science has had an on-off relationship with the American polity since the end of World War II. The external shock of Sputnik provided some of the good years. Fear is a powerful force. But as COVID showed, it can play both ways: fear can turn the public on science as quickly as it can turn them against it. In any case, we can’t wait for external events. The recent bad years are not just the result of anti-science ideology. Communication plays an important role, and it needs to be better honed to be broader and more focused on what support for science means as a social contract, writ large, and not at the level of single grants or institutions.